I love tuna. Fresh, canned, or frozen – bring it on. But is it just me or does anyone else feel a bit overwhelmed by the different species and cuts on offer when buying this deliciously versatile fish? What’s more, a voice at the back of my head wants to know if I’m making an environmentally sound choice.
Unlike wine, cheese and beef, say – for which we have rich vocabularies – common knowledge of different varieties of tuna, their tastes, textures and optimal pairings is the exclusive preserve of specialist chefs and pescatarian gourmands. The differences can be subtle between tuna species and their shifting sustainability status, so here’s a guide to help you go that extra mile and know your yellowfin from your albacore or a $1 tin of skipjack from wallet-busting cuts in restaurants and sashimi joints.
Where it's from: Caught in the tropical waters of the Pacific, Atlantic, and Indian Oceans. The 'tiddler' of the commercial tuna species is also the most abundant. Skipjack, which as the name suggests, likes to leap across the ocean surface, represents 58 percent of the world’s tuna catch.
If you’re eating tuna as a store-cupboard staple then there’s a good bet it’s skipjack. Often labeled 'Chunk Light' in America, it is not technically considered a ‘true’ member of the Thunnus tribe, and upmarket chefs give it a wide berth. That said, its small, tender chunks are perfect for canning and its darker flaky meat has a distinct, strong fish flavor. This makes it a superb pop-top standby for everything from packed lunches and pasta dishes to quick salads and camping trips. Skipjack is the only one of these tunas not commonly eaten raw as sushi.
Try skipjack in cheesy tuna and spring onion melts, pan-fried tuna and parsley patties or in a creamy mayo and lemon-based tuna sauce (tonnato) as a dip for raw or charred vegetables.
Skipjack stocks are healthy in all ocean regions and, at the time of writing, no overfishing is occurring. You will find FAD-free, pole-and-line, or purse-seine caught skipjack tuna available in stores. FADs or fish aggregating devices are man-made floats used to attract tuna; purse seine fishing, which represents 66 percent of global tuna catches, sets a net around a school of tuna, and then pulls it closed like a purse. All of these fishing techniques face challenges when it comes to sustainability, but these can be overcome with careful management and by adapting fishing gear. MSC certified skipjack is, of course, from sustainable sources.
© David Loftus
Where it's from: It is typically caught in deeper waters, around 400m deep, and is found in the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans, the Mediterranean, and even in UK waters. Albacore represents just five percent of the world’s tuna catch.
Deli favorite Albacore is a light-fleshed tuna increasingly found in attractively labeled jars and retro tins with extra virgin olive oil. It comes in larger chunks than skipjack, has a subtle, delicate flavor and drier, meaty texture. It is extremely popular in US grocery stores where it is known as both ‘white tuna’ and ‘chicken of the sea’ – the latter is an old fishermen’s term derived from its light appearance and mild flavor. Be warned: when you see a menu that offers ‘white tuna’ and not ‘albacore’ it could well be an inferior substitute for albacores such as oilfish, butterfish, or escolar.
Albacore is commonly known as Bonito del Norte in Portugal and Spain wherein the north is served as a tapa dish or ‘pintxo’ in stuffed piquillo peppers mixed with a little mayonnaise, finely diced onion and a generous squeeze of lemon juice. King of the cans is ‘Ventresca de Bonito’ – oil-rich belly fillets of albacore which have been carefully cooked in open cauldrons to yield a soft texture and a depth of flavor enhanced by the fish’s appetite for anchovies. The good news is it’s available in MSC certified tins in some supermarkets and stores. Due to its higher fat content than skipjack and the fact its meat holds together nicely, albacore is also sold as fresh and frozen steak. It is great, lightly grilled for a classic Salade Nicoise, on a crushed olive and fava bean crostini or in a Sicilian-style linguine dish with capers and raisins.
© David Loftus
Where it's from: Found throughout the Pacific, Indian, and Atlantic Oceans, yellowfin represent 29 percent of the world’s tuna catch.
More than three-quarters of the world’s tuna catch is consumed in Japan and the most widely served tuna in its 30,000 sushi bars is yellowfin. It is also the tuna most commonly served raw or cooked in European restaurants and the best-selling or most widely consumed MSC-certified tuna in the US. Ruddy colored, leaner, and more affordable than bigeye or bluefin, it appears on menus as sashimi and nigiri or lightly seared in tekkamaki rolls.
Its firm flesh works well grilled, or seared rare to medium-rare. A flash-in-the-pan light touch is key with tuna – overcook it and you might as well be eating cardboard. Yellowfin’s medium-to-mild flavor also makes it an ideal candidate to be marinated – try it cubed and soaked in soy sauce, sesame oil and ginger then served with avocado, edamame, and rice in a bright and healthy Hawaiian poke bowl.
Tuna tidbit: Tuna can earn one of four grades according to its freshness, size and shape, color, texture, and fat content. Grade No. 1 (‘sashimi-grade’ or ‘sushi-grade’) is the best with visible marbled fat and the highest fat content. Grade No. 2+ is excellent quality, perhaps from smaller fish with a few imperfections. Grade No. 2 is ‘grill-grade’ mainly used cooked in restaurants and raw in some lower-end sushi bars. Grade 3 has already turned brown or greenish and is used for cooking.
Where it's from: Found in the Indian, Pacific, and Atlantic Oceans, bigeye represents eight percent of the world’s tuna catch.
Bigeye has fattier flesh than yellowfin with marbling near the skin and a more pronounced richer flavor. Bright red and firm it makes excellent sashimi and meaty steaks. It is one of the two species known as ‘ahi’, along with yellowfin. Try soy and sesame-crusted bigeye with a ginger dressing, grilled spicy mango, and bigeye skewers, or rapidly sear it in a griddle pan and serve with a lustrous caponata.
Three of the world’s bigeye tuna stocks are in good health, but the Atlantic is overfished. To be sure that you’re eating sustainable bigeye, look for the blue MSC label.
Tuna tidbit: Tuna’s natural redness comes from myoglobin, a protein that stores and processes oxygen. Fresh tuna turns brown within hours but this doesn’t affect the taste.
Where it's from: There are three bluefin species in four stocks: Western Atlantic, Eastern Atlantic, and the Mediterranean, Pacific, and Southern. They represent just one percent of the world’s tuna catch.
Bluefin is the kingpin of the tuna family renowned for fetching six-figure sums from exclusive restaurateurs at Tokyo's famous Tsukiji fish market. It has a history of severe overfishing, has been removed from most restaurant menus in North America and Europe and is only really found at high-end sushi restaurants. Thanks to international efforts, however, there are signs of recovery within one bluefin stock in the North-East Atlantic, giving hope that the fate of this much-valued fish can be turned around.
Whether you’re choosing fresh, frozen, or canned, buying sustainable tuna can be a tricky business. There are lots of labels out there competing for the consumer’s attention. Dolphin-safe labels, for example, focus only on the impact of fishing on dolphins and don’t take overall sustainability into account. The best way to significantly reduce exposure to risks such as overfishing, the problem of bycatch, mislabelling and illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing is to choose the distinctive blue label of MSC certified tuna.
Nick Wyke is a journalist and food writer who is passionate about local, seasonal and sustainable produce.
Find a new favorite dish in our collection of sustainable seafood recipes from expert chefs.
For cooks of all levels, check out these tips and tricks for the best sustainable seafood dishes.